|Beatles 1||David H||David H|
|David A||David C||David C|
|David A||David A||David C||David A|
And this was the eventual week that no one would get anything right. I feel bad for my dad in a way because he was really sticking by his guns with his bold Syesha prediction, but hey, who knew she'd even make it this far right?
Though Sleazak won't say that Syesha truly deserved to be in the top 2, he will say that she deserved a fair fight -- something Sleazak thinks Syesha did NOT get with the way the producers and judges treated her last night.
In a season where my very favorite TV show has repeatedly undermined its own credibility — judging some contestants before they've actually performed, praising others even when they noticeably botch kind-of-important details like, oh, their lyrics — it would've been nice if the Mistress of the Bottom Two had been allowed to compete on a musically level playing field with the dueling Davids. [Entertainment Weekly]
Do you think Syesha deserved to get the boot?
I Don't Care
Who would you have wanted to go instead?
Who do you want to win American Idol?
Who do you think will win American Idol?
Syesha Mercado - Eliminated May 15, 2008
Yes Syesha's got talent. There's no doubt about it. I guess what's lacking with her is just that star quality. She's the unfortunate victim of the Idol conspiracy because the producers have been rooting for a David-David finale since the beginning. Because if you were to ask me if Syesha deserves to be in the finale, then she surely does. I guess the support of the Fanesha 300 just wasn't enough. Still, I will always remember her stellar performances of "If I Were Your Woman," "One Rock and Roll Too Many," and even "I Will Always Love You." She is this year's Melinda Doolittle in a sense that she consistently performed but just wasn't the favored one. I'm sure she'll do good with whatever she decides to come out with. Bye Bye Syesha.