I'm not a Good Charlotte fan either, but I actually appreciate some of their songs. The fact that they worked so hard to get were they are right now -- like everyone else, merits a lot for me. And still, I don't quite think they are hot enough for me.
Maybe I'm into the pretty boys, maybe I like guys who shout model look alike, and maybe they just don't rock my boat, but I guess diversity is the key word when it comes to conjuring up lists like these. All the readers have to be satisfied and they surely are enough for other readers. As for me though, not quite my thing.
**out of a possible five