So I got very few correct predicitons this week which only goes to show that the Idols are really going for songs with absolutely no recall (at least not with me). I only know two of the songs sung tonight and well I don't know if that's a good thing or not. I thought my choices were good so I hope tonight's performances are better than expected.
( Onto Patty's Supposedly Objective Commentary )

My Bottom Three
4. David A
4. Jason
4. Brooke

So obviously I think Brooke should go, but because I predicted her for next week, I wouldn't mind if Syesha got the boot first then followed by Brooke which makes way for an all boys top 3. My dream top 3 (The three boys). And yes, I may have put Jason and David A in the bottom 3, but they all averaged a 4. Believe me. I wouldn't even put them there if I were totally biased.

( Take the Poll )

DialIdol says that Syesha is NUMBER 1, followed by David Cook while David A, Brooke and Jason are in the bottom 3. I doubt the Arch Angels will allow for Little David to get the boot. Tomorrow, it's anything goes. I can't wait. And please, someone please gag Paula or rather sock Nigel please.

Last night was not my favorite theme ever. It would have been if they all followed our predictions for them, but alas that just wasn't the case. I feel like there were so many other better songs from the Neil Diamond catalog that were left unused. Oh well, we'll just have to face the consequences of these actions.( Say goodbye to... )
Brooke White - Eliminated May 1, 2008
Oh Brookie. In the beginning, I loved you. I really did. Save for your repeating songs from the start, you weren't half bad. You made it to the top 5 after all!!! I will always enjoy your Top 24 performances of "You're So Vain" and "Love is a Battlefield." When you hit the top 12, there were some snags, but I really like listening to your studio recordings of "You've Got a Friend" and "Every Breath You Take" (where you don't repeat the start). I can imagine your album will be full of folksy tunes that you play on the piano or guitar and I might even get a copy. You had a sort of good run. So congratulations for making it this far. Don't worry, I don't think you'll need to nanny after this.